When was Paris Hilton in an abusive relationship?

Search: Paris Hilton is an Abusive Relationship

Why: On the Superficial list "2009: A Bunch of Shit that Happened":

Paris Hilton is an Abusive Relationship

This was probably the only moment in my entire life where I felt like everything was right in the world. Always dare to dream, my friends. Always, dare to dream.

[sic]

Answer: November? From 11/18:

Paris Hilton and Doug Reinhardt reportedly got into another drunken brawl this morning, according to TMZ:

Paris Hilton and Doug Reinhardt got into an epic fight early this morning ... so much so the LAPD responded to a call -- "Drunk people arguing" -- this, according to law enforcement sources.
It happened a few hours ago in the Hollywood Hills. An eyewitness tells us he saw Paris in her driveway and Doug getting in his car, when Paris began screaming, "Don't go, don't go!"
The eyewitness tells us Doug got out of the car and the lovebirds began "shoving each other."

Sonofabitch. How many times do I have to explain to Doug Reinhardt he won't go to jail for murdering Paris in a "crime of passion?" No, really, I dare you to find one person who'd convict him let alone an entire jury. It's the greatest legal loophole known to man.

And a follow-up article:

Captain Birdfoot of the S.S. Barnacled Clam is denying she was involved in a fight with Doug Reinhardt that ended in the cops showing up at her house, according to TMZ:

"Doug and I were in bed, sound asleep, when Doug's houseguests from hell got into an argument. We had nothing to do with it. Doug told the LAPD that his guests' fight was over and that we had nothing to do with it."
Ok, sounds credible, except for the neighbor who says he eyeballed Paris in her driveway screaming at BF Doug Reinhardt, and then watched as the two engaged in a mutual shoving match. And then there's the LAPD, who tells us after arriving they actually made Paris get out of bed so they could check for injuries.

If Paris is afraid to admit she's in an abusive relationship because she'll be encouraged to break up with Doug, she really shouldn't be. In fact, I'd like to pay for the wedding. Let's make this thing permanent, you crazy lovebirds!

Source: The Superficial

The More You Know: Also, he allegedly choked her on Halloween after her threw her cell phone out the window. Idk. Ctm.